“Proficiency in accounting work is largely a matter of experience and judgment; the underlying theory of the science is not particularly profound. The test comes when we attempt to apply the general fundamentals to the infinitely varied and complex situations found in the world of commerce. Factual information and accuracy in its procurement are essential, but its value is submerged unless with it is synchronized the development and training of the judgment...the solution of business problems not only calls for an orderly marshalling of facts, but, what is equally important, careful analysis and logical reasoning from such facts, the formation and establishing of effective conclusions and the exercise of sound judgment.” (This quote is drawn from the article by Kris A. Mapp, FCA, "
Educating Our Students - What Is Our Responsibility?"
Canadian Chartered Accountant, October 1937, page 258.)
“According to the academic research literature, the exercise of professional judgment by those preparing and auditing financial accounting information is at the core of financial reporting. Without the flexibility and the intelligence provided by professional judgment, the complex system of financial accounting procedures, standards and rules would be ponderous, unresponsive, insensitive: in short, unworkable. Financial reporting, as it operates in Canada and elsewhere, requires professional judgment at many levels, in a host of circumstances, and by a variety of skilled and experienced professionals. In fact, professional judgment is an essential part of financial reporting.” (This quote is drawn from the CICA Research Study,
Professional Judgment in Financial Reporting, Michael Gibbins and Alister K. Mason, 1988, page 1.)
